Victory for pro-life campaigner in harassment battle

A prominent Northern Irish pro-life campaigner has had her conviction for harassment quashed following a court hearing today.

Bernadette Smyth, founder of the Precious Life group, was found guilty on 19th November 2014 of harassing the programme director of Northern Ireland’s first private abortion facility.

Since the opening of the Marie Stopes Belfast facility, Bernadette and others from Precious Life had gathered outside it in order to educate the public about the true nature of abortion.
Bernadette, however, was accused and later convicted of harassing Ms Dawn Purvis who oversaw the facility.

In December, Deputy District Judge Chris Holmes ordered Bernadette Smyth to pay £2,000 in compensation to Ms Purvis, to undertake 100 hours of community service and not to go within 20 yards of the abortion facility for a five year period.

Today, Judge Gordon Kerr overturned the conviction, ruling that there had been insufficient evidence of harassment.

Ms Purvis, a former leader of the Progressive Unionist Party (which has links to loyalist paramilitary groups), claimed that Bernadette Smyth's actions had left her feeling afraid.

Bernadette Smyth's barrister today challenged that claim, asking:

"Are you not a person with a bit more fortitude than that?"

"I was frightened," she replied.

The court was also told that one of the incidents wasn’t reported by Ms Purvis until a day after it was alleged to have happened.

"I thought I could cope with it, but I couldn't. I thought this was another incident I could let go, but I couldn't," she said.

“I was fearful, and all of the protesters were causing me a lot of angst," she claimed.

Bernadette Smyth's lawyer later asked the judge to dismiss the case which he did, concluding that the evidence did not meet the standard required to secure a conviction.
 

"Lovingly reach out"

Bernadette Smyth has previously explained:

“The sole purpose of our presence outside the Marie Stopes centre in Belfast is to defend human life and reach out with support to mothers with unexpected pregnancies.

“We do not harass or intimidate — we lovingly reach out to women with practical, caring solutions which uphold the dignity of both mother and child. Women deserve better than abortion.”
 

'Spotlight needed on Marie Stopes' activities'

Andrea Williams, chief executive of the Christian Legal Centre which has welcomed the decision, commented:

"We are delighted that Bernadette Smyth has been cleared of the charge against her. She should never have been convicted in the first place. Bernadette Smyth and Precious Life are involved in courageous work to expose the truth about abortion and to speak for unborn children in Northern Ireland and across the UK. We stand with her wholeheartedly.

"The spotlight will again be focused on the reality of abortion and the activities of Marie Stopes as a manslaughter case comes to the Old Bailey this Friday."

Related News:
Judge finds against pro-life campaigner  
Pro-life activist sentanced over harassment

Related Coverage:
Bernadette Smyth: Anti-abortion protester wins appeal (BBC)