Skip to content

Archive site notice

You are viewing an archived copy of Christian Concern's website. Some features are disabled and pages may not display properly.

To view our current site, please visit

Christian Magistrate in Legal Appeal over Christian Conscience

Printer-friendly version ANDREW McClintock, a Sheffield-based Magistrate on the family panel, in Court asking to be excused from presiding over cases where the outcome might be the placing of a child in a same-sex household.

Monday 22 October 2007

Christian Magistrate in Legal Appeal over Christian Conscience

ANDREW McClintock, a magistrate on the Family Panel was in Court on 22nd October asking to be excused from cases where he may have to place children into same-sex households.

Mr McClintock, a Christian, was represented at the Employment Appeal Tribunal in London by Paul Diamond, Barrister, and the case was expected to last one day. He appealed against the decision of the Sheffield Employment Tribunal.

On 6th February 2006, Mr. McClintock was forced to resign from membership of the Family Panel as he felt unable to place children in a same sex household, and the court refused to allow him to be screened from those cases. Mr McClintock felt there was a conflict of law as he felt the welfare of the child was best served by placing him or her in a family with a mother and a father.

A full report on this case and its implications will be emailed as soon as the Court has handed down its judgement.

Andrea Minichiello Williams